Vancouver Swimming Community Events

How to Prepare Yourself for Open Water Swimming

by Peter Scott, Sea Hiker Coach

Several triathletes have already approached me wondering how they should prepare for their first open water race with a wetsuit. 

This is a great and very smart question. There is a world of difference between pool swimming and open water swimming. In one word: distractions.

 

Triathlon Mayhem

 

As you try to think about your swim stroke, breathing and pace, you will be distracted every few seconds by other swimmers beside you, waves and current, sunshine, whatever anxieties or questions you might have about who or what is sharing the water with you. And then of course, you're racing!

 

But that's why open water is so addictive. It's a fantastic experience once you feel more familiar in your surroundings and have an idea of what to expect.

 

If you're asking the question of what you should expect in your first open water race, you're well ahead of the game.

 

I know of many triathletes who put this off. It's not easy to think about, there are so many unknowns and decisions to make.

 

Case in point: There are triathletes who race having never tried on their wetsuit (except once in the tri shop). gasp!…I know, can you believe it?

Bad idea.

 

 

That's when you find out that your suit fit snugly in the store, but made it impossible to breathe while swimming in the water. Or that water leaks in your sleeves on every stroke. Or that your neck seal lets water into your suit in a new freezing high pressured stream.

 

These are not things you want to discover on race day.

 

I understand human nature. We tend to shy away from doing the things that seem too complex, daunting or requiring a sequence of decisions.

 

This is why we don't practice breathing on our weaker side, let's all admit it.

 

But if this is your first foray into open water swimming, you should know the basics.

 

So here's a short primer on what you should expect, followed by a checklist of things to try before your race.

Cold Water

Yes, the water can be a bit of a shock. Your best bet is to explore this new sensation well before race day. Bring a friend for safety and so you have a real bonding experience.

 

Bay Challenge Race - Peter

 

Put on your wetsuit (see the checklist at the end of this article, though, first). As you wade into waist deep water, splash your face and neck to help prepare your body for the immersion and that inevitable trickle down the back of your neck.

 

This is actually really important.  It helps you avoid the gasping effect that often happens in cold water. When you're in cold water, you really need to have your breathing under control, for safety and swimming performance.

 

In fact, if you take a few short hyperventilations, say 3-6 quick, hard breaths, you'll have just a little extra buffer for when you start to swim. And you'll be in control of your own breathing.

 

For your first trial swim, pick a beach with a gently sloping bottom (ask your friends) and swim parallel to shore about 10m away from the water's edge. This is an important safety point for trying on a new suit. Why? Because it might leak, the zipper might break, or you could tear a hole, resulting in a mass of chilly water washing through your suit.

 

This is why swimming with a friend is always a great idea and something you should always do.

 

But if you take these precautions, and wear socks and gloves for super cold water, then you should be fine.

 

 

 

Sea Hiker Water Temperature Scale.


 
Here's our scientific temperature scale (from the scientific advisor):

 

6-9 Celsius: Winter water temperatures in Vancouver. You swim can swim in relative comfort in winter months, as long as you have a neoprene cap, socks and gloves. For most people, bare hands and feet suck the warmth out too fast and so are not practical or safe for long swims, especially if you are swimming out away from shore. A swim buddy, as always, is highly recommended. Despite gloves and socks, your feet and hands will tend to get cold no matter what you do, even if your body stays warm.

10-12 Celsius: Your bare hands and feet will be really cold, they may immediately start to ache when you enter the water. When you put your face in the water, you may get an ice-cream headache for the first 5-10 minutes or so. Head up swimming, lots of breathing (every two strokes) is really helpful. It's hard to relax in this kind of cold water, so don't think you should be relaxed. Do you best until you actually warm up. Again, stay close to shore if this is new to you.

 

13-15 Celsius: That's what the water is like right now in Howe Sound and close to shore in English Bay. You will still feel a chill on your hands and feet, maybe a slight bone chill on your ankles and wrists. But it's bearable. Once you start moving, you can settle in and start to relax after 5 minutes. But you'll really have to keep moving! 

16-18 Celsius: Refreshing and great for long or fast swims. You'll feel a little breathless in the first 5 minutes as you warm up, but that will soon fade. No aching limbs or ice cream headaches. This is the coldest it gets for most ocean triathlons in summer time, with the exception of tides that churn up the deeper water and send cooler layers to the surface.

19-21 Celsius: Ahh, summer. This is the sweet spot for swimmers in a full wetsuit. You could easily swim without a wetsuit for while, but in a wetsuit, you'll be able to swim and swim without worrying about getting cold. On a hot sunny day, you might even need to flush your suit to stay cool.

22+ Celsius: Now we're getting somewhere. We do occasionally get water temperatures in the 22 Celsius mark, generally close to shore and after a few days of hot sun and no wind. In a wetsuit, you'll feel toasty warm, and probably too hot if you swim for any long duration, unless you're wearing a long john (no arms) or a shorty.



How the Wetsuit Changes Your Stroke

Most triathlon wetsuits are buoyant, and in my opinion, too buoyant for most people, especially in the legs and mid-section.

 

Balance: It is true that putting the maximum thickness in the legs helps most swimmers avoid dragging their legs behind them. But it also prevents you from kicking as efficiently as you can in the pool, changes your sense of balance, and makes it more challenging to control your body rotation on each stroke.

If you've been improving your balance in the pool with your head or lead arm position and succeeding, you will find you'll need to adjust your stroke further with this added buoyancy. You can tilt your head up slightly to sink your legs. But be careful that you're not arching your back - over longer swims this can lead to a sore lower back and neck.

Breathing: Breathing is whole lot easier because you just can't sink. This is good because chop and small waves can make breathing a little more tricky.  The main thing you have to make sure of is that breathing in and out is not restricted by the wetsuit. It is normal to feel some compression of the suit on your torso and chest, but you should still be able to breathe with ease. If not, exchange your suit for one that fits you.

Wetsuit Temptations: It is easy to let yourself relax in a wetsuit, you float like a cork. This is a great foundation for your confidence. However, if you let your legs dangle like noodles and your torso sag in the middle, you will still lose lots of speed as you move through the water. Swim like a torpedo, not like Gollum! Keep your core engaged, try to use your legs to stabilize your upper body, and find a way to feel stable in the water without lifting your head and lead arm too high.

Shoulders and Neck: Chaffing and tight shoulders are another consideration. Even with body glide or a similar product - a transparent odourless deodorant-style stick - applied to your neck, arms  and anywhere that might chafe against itself or the liner of your suit, you should still check your suit for obvious areas of note. One silly thing to watch for is raised stiching on the neck, this is almost guaranteed to chafe and rub your neck. You may not notice this in the water, but you will certainly notice it once you get out and while it might be a badge of courage for your race, it's something you can avoid or minimize.

Air pockets in your suit: If you can handle it, it's a great idea to pull the collar of your suit away from your neck and let water flush down your suit. Stand up and squeeze the water out - you'll find more space in your suit and an ability to slide it into the right position.

 

You can then eliminate any air pockets and improve the way the suit fits your body (thanks to Lynne from Switching Gears Triathlon Club for this great tip).  But, make sure the water isn't 12 Celsius! Otherwise, you'll be very cold and tense before you even start.

Swimming in Open Water

There's so much to cover here, and if you can, try one of our open water courses or Kits Pool Tri Clinics, but if we had to narrow it down to three things you should experience before your first race, it's this:

1. Stay warm: On a hot race day, with the sun overhead, it might be a great idea to jump in the water, a few minutes before your race to acclimatize to the water and the conditions of that day.

 

If it is early morning and freezing cold, you can opt to splash your face and neck a few times as a compromise. You're still giving your body a fair warning for the cold water immersion to come, but you're not sacrificing valuable body heat.

 

Standing around waiting for a race start in early morning cool air or rain is bad enough, don't compromise your comfort and performance by getting chilled before your start.


For your practice swims, swim for as long as you can stay warm. This will help to build an enjoyment of swimming in a wetsuit and will help you stay relaxed.

 

 

2. Breathe in Enough, Exhale More: There are no rules for breathing. The only thing you really need to do is breathe well enough and often enough so that it matches the level of work that you're doing.
   
In cold water, you need to breathe even more than usual. You will very naturally feel like gasping in very cold water, so it is good to actually start breathing quite rapidly and forcefully for 3-6 breaths before you even start swimming, as described above.

 

Focus on breathing as often as possible in the first 250-400m of your swim. This means ensuring that you're exhaling enough C02 from your lungs to prevent that unpleasant feeling of burning lungs. 

 

If this means breathing on the same side - every two strokes, so be it. That's perfectly fine and an excellent strategy that I use all the time. Once you relax and feel "warmed up" you can switch to whatever breathing style works best for you.

In an open water race, breathe often and focus on exhaling lots of air as you turn your head and opening your mouth wide so you can inhale with ease. The less you have to gasp, the safer you will feel when it comes to breathing. If you don't open your mouth wide enough, you just won't exchange enough air, and this can lead to uncontrolled gasping.

 

For your practice swims, focus on breathing first, then when you feel relaxed and warmed up, then cast your attention on smoothing out your stroke.

3. Look Ahead to Stay On Course:

 

The biggest rookie mistake for new open water swimmers is to put the head down and just swim. I can totally understand that. It's easier, it allows you to focus on the skills you've been practicing, it allows you to relax. But if you don't check your bearings every 10-12 strokes at a minimum, chances are you are swimming way off course.

 

Contrary to what you may have heard, there are no black lines and lane ropes in the ocean (although I've head that some lakes have them - it takes a lot of time, but scuba divers install floating reflective mylar strips at about 10 feet underwater so you can see them at the surface, .... honest).

 

So you need to keep an eye out for the general direction of traffic and the marker buoys. If you're swimming on shore, aim for a big tree, buoy, boat (moored, not in motion) or try to stay parallel to shore. Both are great navigation exercises.

 

A good think to get into the habit of doing is counting strokes between sighting strokes (when you tilt and slightly lift your head to look forward as an arm drive ahead of into the water). You don't have to do this all the time, but if it is new to you, it's a good idea. Count to 8-10 strokes and then figure out how you're going to look ahead.

 

In flat water with good steering on your part, 10-12 strokes might be fine. In choppy water with current and lots of people in your way, every 4-5 strokes might be required.  But the energy and time you save by swimming in straight line usually outweighs the energy it takes to sight forward.

 

If you find you are stopping completely in the water to look up and really lifting your head, you need to learn the sighting technique, which makes a big difference, and allows you to keep the flow of your swim going.

 

For your practice swim, test your ability to swim in a straight line. How many strokes before you veer off course? This will change, though, as the water conditions change. The more current and wave action, the harder you will find swimming in a straight line.


Leave Your Race in the Water

 

And finally, accept that the water has other ideas for you. That's part of the adventure of open water swimming. You can do your best for that day, but it is possible that the water might be too cold, or the waves too choppy or the field of swimmers too aggressive. That's just part of the adventure.  Chalk it up as valuable experience for next time.

 

The best advice I can give you is to approach your first race from a "soft style" perspective. Start out as relaxed as possible and gradually pick up your pace when and only if you feel a sense of comfort in your surroundings.

 

In a triathlon, especially your first few races, your goal should be to feel energized and warmed up after your swim.

 

Start there and everything will follow.


 

Wetsuit Checklist

 

Try out your wetsuit in a warm pool before taking it outside. Try some or all of these recommended steps.

 

At home:

  • Read the instructions for putting on your suit without ripping it, and follow the recommendations.
  • Gradually put on the suit inch, by inch, pulling from the inside material (nylon), not the outside (super fragile smooth skin neoprene).
  • Discover if you can zip up your suit on your own. Arrange for someone to be there with you, otherwise a tri suit does interfere somewhat with work obligations and your social life.
  • Buy some anti-chaffing product for your neck and other tender parts. Try it on.


At the Pool:

  • Put the suit on dry, it's much easier. Do not have a shower beforehand! Time yourself. This could be important for race day. You don't want to rush putting on the suit, that's how you can get flustered, anxious and even injure your hands or suit.
  • Once it's on, to get an even better fit, open the neck of the suit to let some water in. This will help you readjust the suit if it sticks on certain body parts. Stand up to let the water drain before swimming. This is especially important for your chest area and shoulders.
  • Explore the feeling of water pressure compressing the neoprene around your chest. You may feel a bit uncomfortable here. This is natural. However, if it feels like a crushing pressure, and you can't breathe at all, then the suit may be too tight.
  • Swim for a few 100m. Can you kick well? You may be tempted not to kick at all, but this will cause you some problems for your stroke, as you will have a hard time rotating effectively on each stroke.
  • Swim for a few more 100m. How does your breathing feel? You will feel higher in the water, so that will be nice. Pay attention to whether your chest feels like it can fully inhale. This is very important. You need to be able to breathe freely. If you can't, exchange you suit for one that fits snugly but still lets you breathe normally.
  • Swim for a few more 100m. Check your speed per 100m with a relaxed swim. You may notice you're swimming faster or with less effort. This will help you estimate your seed time, if you need to provide one for your race.
  • Swim for 500m. If you're getting to hot, flush the suit again. This time, add sighting to your stroke (looking ahead over the water). Try to keep your head low when you look up so you don't slow down. Stroke counting is a nice test for this, too.   
  • Check to see if you feel any strain on your lower back. Some suits are very buoyant in the legs and torso panels, so this can create a problem for some people.

   

Taking the suit off:

  • Try taking the suit off. Again, read the instructions on how to get your suit off. Try it slowly the first time and then with speed in transition. 
  • Rinse your suit out as much as possible to keep it alive. I don't normally recommend swimming in a pool with a wetsuit, but 1-2 times won't hurt it. 
  • Dry the suit draped over a shower door or chair. Do not leave it out in the sun or hanging from a hanger. This will stretch out the shoulers and put more tension on the seems.
  • Dry out your suit inside out, then put it back to normal for storage. Your suit will last longer.

 

Any tips for me to add?  Contact us to contribute to this list.

   


How to Save Your Shoulders Pain - Part III - How Kicking Saves the Day

How Kicking Can Save Your Shoulders

by Peter Scott, Sea Hiker Coach

In part III of this article, we look at the role of kicking in keeping our shoulders healthy and why a poor kick is bad news for your shoulders.

You might be getting back into swimming this month, toying with the idea of triathlons this spring or joining one of our swim pods. 

The one thing that can mess up your plans in a major way is shoulder pain, tendonitis or injury. 

There's nothing more demoralizing to a swimmer than shoulder issues. If you have them now, see a doctor or physiotherapist, stop swimming and allow your shoulder to fully recover. 

But if you are looking for swimming-specific prevention ideas, read on. 

Kick Like a Kung Fu Master

Picture this: A kung fu master, standing on a rocky ledge under a thick stand of bamboo. His legs are spread apart and his arms are drawn back into coiled fists. He stays still, breathing slowly, in and out.

 

Kung Fu Master

 

Then suddenly, he explodes into motion, arms whirling, palms striking, elbows deflecting, and the air crackling with energy. Then, he is still again, legs as solid as rock, yet able to move with ease.

 

The bamboo sways in the breeze.

 

The legendary kung fu master can exert tremendous force, finesse and accuracy with his arms because he has learned how to stand. He can stand in one place for hours, which is something most of us cannot do.

 

He understands that without a good stance and balance, his arms cannot deflect a blow, without his legs anchoring him to the ground, he will easily be pushed over. If he cannot master the art of standing with little effort, he will always lose when attacked. 

 

He tries to be like the bamboo. Firmly rooted in the ground and yet agile, able to bend and sway, no matter how strong the wind gets.

 

Cautionary note: I once tried to dig up bamboo in my days before Sea Hiker. It took me 5 hours, a pick axe, and left me more exhausted and drained than any workout I have ever done in my life. I felt like throwing up. So, moral of the story is don't try to uproot a kung fu master. 

 

What does this have to do with swimming?

 

Well, I knew we'd come to that.

 

You need a good stance to swim well. And if you're not thinking about this, best to start today. The bamboo has a head start and it grows like crazy.

 

The Secret of Kicking Is....

 

Kicking, the act of creating water pressure around your legs and feet, allows you to create stability for body rotation. We all know why body rotation is important: it is how you can get to air, how you reduce drag and how you ensure that your shoulders don't explode into crunchy bits when you swim.

 

Kicking does indeed have a role in helping you propel your body forward, but I would argue that for most people, the most important thing it helps you with is to give you a stable platform for the movements of your upper body and torso.

 

If you think about any 50m sprinter in the Olympics, they swim at very high stroke rates and they kick incredibly hard and fast. Without a strong kick they would simply not have the ability to rotate back and forth with such aggression and precision.

 

A high level triathlete in an open water race, using a higher stroke rate, also needs a skilled kicking technique to stabilize as they stroke and breathe and sight ahead. It doesn't matter if it is a two beat kick or flutter kick, the stability must be there.

 

The novice swimmer, trying to breathe to one side as she swims in full stroke, needs to trust that when she rotates to one side, she will be able to rotate far enough to find air.

 

Quite simply, kicking gives you the "stance" in the water that allows you to have a good body roll, weight shift, and rotation on each stroke.

 

Here's a very simple experiment you can try to explore this idea of "stance" and its effect on your body position:


  • Swim 100-200m, depending on your skill level, without any kicking whatsoever. Have someone watch you to make sure you are not cheating!
  • Swim 100-200m with a relaxed but high tempo flutter kick, with your tempo per a fast "one-two! one-two!" (or 0.25 seconds per kick). This doesn't mean you're kicking HARD, just fast. Keep your knees and ankles floppy.
  • Swim 100-200m with fins at the same fast tempo. Same fast and floppy kick.
  • Swim 100-200m with no kick again.
  • Repeat this twice.

 

For each rep of 100-200m, keep track of your swim time, ease of breathing to both sides, and form.

 

On the second round, pay closer attention to your arm recovery and shoulders when you don't have any kick at all. Do your arms, hands and shoulders feel relaxed? (If they do you may have slowed down too much)

 

Note: The more skilled a swimmer you are, the easier this will be, but the difference should be noticeable all the same.

 

Without an effective kick to help you get into a rotated body position, you will again end up in a flatter swimming position and have to resort to some kind of swinging or chicken wing recovery, which, as we saw in part II of this article series, is bad news.

 

Without your kick to stabilize you for body rotation, you end up like this in the water:

 

 

Elbow behind shoulder - swimming flat 

With a good stabilized kick, you will look like this:

 

Relaxed Recovery with Wide Elbow

 

The Marks of An Ineffective Kick

 

From an efficiency standpoint, the ineffective kick  causes the following problems:

 

1. Swimming flat makes breathing tough: Your body wants to float in a flat position. That's how your lungs are set-up and you have the best displacement and buoyancy in this position. Too bad you can't really breathe efficiently here! (unless you lift your head, but then you sink)

 

2. Drag: Goodbye streamline and hello human brick. Swimming flat dramatically increases frontal resistance.

 

3. A short, choppy stroke: Without the stabilizing force of your kicking, you will rely on your hands more for stability, especially during the breath. This can cause a wide array of problems including the pushing down on your lead arm during the breath (another brick posture), straight arm pull (stressing the shoulder) and a windmill stroke timing (for most people this is slow, and inefficient).

 

4. Shoulder impingment: And finally, as in the first photo above, swimming flat prevents you from having a relaxed shoulder during the recovery phase over the water.

 

 

But Kicking Is So Much More Effort!

 

Yep, an inefficient flutter kick is really hard work, but an efficient kick is not.  If you tend to get leg cramps when you swim or feel extremely out of breath after a 50m swim, that's a likely sign that you're using the wrong muscles to kick and no doubt that is proving to be a big deterrent to more kicking.

 

A relaxed high tempo flutter kick with good technique doesn't take that much effort. You just need the specific skills and awareness to acheive it.

 

 

I really, really hate using a kickboard, though. Do I have to?

 

Kicking with a kickboard is really challenging. It is a great conditioning tool, and that's why a lot of competitive swimmers use one. But they generally already have a high level of kicking skill to start with or the luxury of many years in a swim club to gradually develop it as kids.

 

Most swimmers and triathletes do not have the time, fitness or skill for a kick board.

 

Don't get me wrong, you should try one out now and then, if only to gauge your kicking skill progress and try it as a challenge. 

 

If you're a pool swimmer, competiting in Masters' meets, it's a good thing to use as a tool.

 

Many of my clients have struggled for years to kick well with a kickboard, with their coaches just wanting them to kick harder.  I believe that lots of kickboard sets makes it very hard to learn the essentials of efficient kicking.

 

Why?

 

  1. Your head is usually high, putting pressure on your lower back, sinking your legs, and forcing most people (triathletes and runners, especially) to kick from the knee, not the hips.
  2. Kicking so that you move forward with any kind of decent speed is very hard work because of the drag your legs create. This makes it harder for you to kick with good technique for more than 25m without getting too tired. To improve your swimming stability, you should be able to kick effectively all the time, not just for 25m. 

If you're discouraged with your kicking, whether it's with a kickboard or not, start with the exercises below first and then try one again.

Kickboard tip: To minimize the poor posture of kickboard kicking, extend your arms in front of you so that your head can rest face down in the water. Also, use the smallest kickboard available so that your upper body isn't floating so high.

Finally, try kicking on your front with an imaginary kickboard. Use sculling with your hand/arms to breathe. :-)

What to do about it

 

The Short Answer: More leg movement at the hip joint and less tension in the knee and ankle.


Face it, you're a land creature and you're built for bipedal locomtion...walking, running and our clever ape-descend genius-inspired activities like cycling, step-aerobics, and.... burpies.

 

The main challenge that you have to overcome is again having little clue how to actually move your leg for the kick and what it should feel like.

 

Move your hip more: Kick deeper (when face down) or thrust your thigh to the ceiling on your back.

 

Relax your knee: Tight quads will stop a good kick before it begins. Your knee should be relaxed.

 

Floppy ankles: Imagine your feet are fins (flippers). The only way that they can bend like a fin, is if they are loose and supple. Yes, flexible ankles and feet really do help, but for most people it's muscle activation and lack of awareness that's the problem. When you run and cycle, you will flex your ankle (the position you're in when you're about to put weight on your foot). This will completely disarm your kicking from the start.

 

High tempo: Kicking too slowly creates more drag, sinks your legs and way more resistance - which means more hard work for you. Move your legs faster, so they feel light and effective.

 

Let's look at some drills to practice in order to get this feeling. 

 

 

Skill Practice - Kicking Sensations

 

1. Kick on your back and make some noise

 

Kick on your back so that you can see, hear and feel your feet at the surface and your thighs moving up. If your ankles are truly loose and floppy, you should feel them bend with water pressure away from your shins, as the ankles extend.

 

If you cannot hear or see your feet breaking the surface, you are either kicking too slowly, lifting your head up too high, bending at the knees too much (tight and active quads!), or just not moving your thigh at the hip joint with a large enough amplitude. Get those feet up!

 

How to feel this on dryland: Well, we can't really reproduce kicking on dry land, but you can feel the hip flexors and upper quads engage with this simple exercise.

 

  • Lie down on your back. Hands resting down the length of your thighs. Lift one knee up slightly so it's relaxed. Then, gently lift your whole leg up a couple of inches, letting your ankle dangle. Repeat this movement several times. Then try it faster. This isn't the whole range of motion for kicking on your back but it helps you focus on initiating the kick from the hip while keeping the ankle and knee loose. Try it.


2. Kicking Face Down with Glute Activation


Now repeat the same exercise as above, this time kicking only while face down with your arms extended in a glide position. To achieve the same range of motion in the hip joint, you need to kick deeper (toward the bottoom). But again, if your legs don't come back up, your legs will create drag and sink.

 

So pull your leg up toward the surface after each kick with your gluteus maximus and hamstring muscles, so that you can drive the leg down with more snap on the next one.

 

Floppy ankles and make some noise at the surface. Feel pressure on your feet. Experiment with the range of motion in your hips, especially. When in doubt, make lots of splash to prove you know where your legs are and then tone it down to a relaxed kick.

 

You still want a high tempo, but with relaxed knees and ankles.

 

When you do it well you will be able to kick at a high tempo but with less effort.

 

How to feel this on dryland:  Feel the glutes activate to pull your leg up higher, so it can drive deeper on the kick in the water. 

 

  • Lie down on your stomach. Arm by your sides or in a push-up position for comfort. Choose one leg and gently pull up your leg (relax the knee and ankle) so that your knee comes off the floor. It's a very small movement. You should be aware of your glute activating.


 

 

3. Swim with Constant Flutter Kicking (mini-laps)

 

Prove the power of a good kick. After playing around with the two exercises above, try some mini-laps of swimming without breathing.

 

Activate your relaxed but high tempo flutter kick and take 4-7 strokes without breathing. Try this 6-8 times at least with a nice rest interval between each rep.

 

As you do this, experiment with your ability to rotate around your head/spine axis. Don't breathe yet!

 

Use your consistent flutter kick to explore how smoothly, quickly, crisply and to what degree you can rotate from side to side.

 

Try a few more mini-laps without breathing with high-tempo flutter kicking and a slow recovery (3-second count) and then a faster one (2-second count). Can you separate your arms tempo from your legs? Sometimes this can be a confusing process.

 

Focus on kicking consistently to support full body rotations on each stroke.


 

4. Mini-Laps with breathing

 

Try the same thing with breathing 1-3 times during your mini-lap. Focus on beginning with an effective flutter kick and think especially of maintaining that consistent flutter when you breathe.

 

You have to split your awareness between breathing and kicking. It's hard, I know. But this is where most people develop bad habits - when they are distracted by breathing.

 

Simply focus on kicking through your breath.

 

 

Final Words


This article has become more about kicking technique than shoulders. But if you don't kick well, I pretty much can guarantee that you are using your arms/hands in inefficient ways to compensate, or are swimming much slower than you could be, with the biggest drag happening when you try to rotate to breathe.

 

And if you are not rotating well, you may be swimming with the chicken recovery or some other such evilness.

 

Words of wisdom from Xiao Jin, kung fu master in the ancient art of You Yong:

 

"Kick well to rotate. Rotate well to breathe and slip past the water dragon. And slip past the water dragon to move your arms with shoulders that will last a thousand years, my young minnow."

 

Next blog post:

 

Part IV: Why We Pull Too Hard and Swim Through Shoulder Pain (Bad!)

How to Save Your Shoulders Pain And Swim Faster - Part II - The Chicken Recovery

 

Stop Swimming Like A Chicken and Set Your Shoulders Free

by Peter Scott, Sea Hiker Coach

Note: There's a video that goes with the blog post. Here it is: http://youtu.be/0WsfHjyacxY  You might want to read this first, then watch the video. 

You might be getting back into swimming this month, toying with the idea of triathlons this spring or joining one of our swim pods. 

The one thing that can mess up your plans in a major way is shoulder pain, tendonitis or injury. 

There's nothing more demoralizing to a swimmer than shoulder issues. If you have them now, see a doctor or physiotherapist, stop swimming and allow your shoulder to fully recover. 

But if you are looking for swimming-specific prevention ideas, read on. 

In part II of this article, we look at the recovery motion, or, how to stop swimming like a chicken. 

Part II: The Chicken Recovery, Crunchy Shoulders and What to Do About It

Okay, the second thing that can cause shoulder strain and injury is how we usually move our recovering arm - the one that's moving above the water on each stroke.


What we do, silly humans, is give in to our deep and powerful instinct to swim like a chicken, which is profoundly misguided. 


Chickens aren't even that good at flying. So who knows where we got the instinct to swim like them. 


Swimming like a chicken is not only bad for your shoulder, it's also bad for business all around, wastes energy and slows you down. 

 

 

The Chicken Recovery and Why It Sucks 

 

Simply put, when you begin to raise your arm and bring it forward, most of us pull the elbow behind your back and shoulder, putting greater strain on the shoulder joint, ligaments and muscles. 

 

This happens for several reasons: 

 

1. You are instinctively engaging the muscles of your back and shoulders to fling your arm forward. This reduces shoulder mobility.

 

2. You are swimming too flat and have to get your arm out of the water somehow. 

 

3. You want to clobber the poor unsuspecting regular swimmer in the lane next to you and you're pulling back your elbow to really give them a solid shot across their bow. 

 

In all cases, what happens is that your shoulder tightens up and gets pulled into an awkward position, which can easily impinge your rotator cuff and cause wear and tear on the shoulder. 

 

Here's a few examples of the chicken wing recovery: 

 

Elbow behind shoulder - swimming flat 

 

The photo below is the second most common occurrence, and it usually happens during the breathing stroke: 

 

Elbow behind shoulder - pulling back elbow


This is an example of the zipper drill gone bad (zipper drill is a pre-cursor to single switch drill, but many people try it and put undue strain on their shoulders - and sink underwater at the same time because all the weight of the arm is right on top of their body): 

 

 

Elbow behind shoulder - zipper recovery

 

Here's what we're aiming for, in general, elbow swinging wide then high away from the body, shoulder nice and loose: 

 

Relaxed Recovery with Wide Elbow

 

The Inefficient Chicken

 

From an efficiency standpoint, the chicken recovery causes the following problems:

 

1. Over-swinging of your arms causing crossing over in front of your head, fishtailing, and general instability.  

 

2. Drag: all that swinging makes you wobble like a 4-year-old learning to ride a bicycle. 

 

3. The tension and exertion to fling your arm forward is wasted and adds nothing to your speed overall. A tight shoulder also means that your shoulder muscles will tire sooner, meaning your stroke is going to break down faster, slowing you down. 

 

4. Your elbow will be lower, closer to the water, and for most swimmers, drain your ability to send your momentum forward on each stroke. 

 

But worst of all, is that the movement is instinctive, so you have no awareness or control over this mechanism - a movement that is potentially bad for your shoulder joint and one that slows you down. 

 

Tracing The Ancient Lineage of Dog Paddle & Windmill to the Present Day Chicken Wing Recovery

 

As we evolved into swimming creatures, we shared a common ancestor who taught us how to swim, along with dogs and horses. We called it the dog paddle, but it should be called the worst swim stroke in the world. 


Then came the windmill stroke - one that is still used at the Olympic level - but a stoke style that is generally not suited to efficient distance swimming or for those of us who can't afford shoulder surgery every year. 

 

So our compromise is the Chicken Recovery. 

 

And so now we've identified yet another instinctive motion that is messing us up and creates a blind spot in our technique. A blind spot is an area that we're not aware off. If we're not aware of it, how can we begin to correct it? 

 

Most recoveries are too quick and sudden, allow little time to evaluate the path of the recovery over the water and how it affects our entry and extension into a streamline on each stroke.

 

This makes it really difficult to learn how better to move the arm forward. 


 

What to do about it

 

The Short Answer: Slow....things....down.

 

The main challenge that you have to overcome is the initial difficulty in being aware of your body position (torso) relative to your arm. 

 

If you are swimming flat, any attempt to lift your elbow above the water will result in a tightening of the shoulder and potentially shoulder impingement. (see the first photo above)

 

If you swim on your side sufficiently, on each body rotation, you have the ability now to bring your elbow forward without impingement. However, you need to swing the elbow away from you to ensure that happens. Even if you rotate enough, you can still pull the elbow behind your back and cause your shoulder problems. (see photos #2 and #3)

 

If you rotate enough AND swing the elbow outward, keeping the arm wide on recovery and entry, then you're off to the races. (photo #4)

 

Let's look at some drills to practice in order to get this feeling. 

 

 

Skill Practice - Shoulder joint awareness during recovery

 

Here's a link to a video that explains most of the points below. Watch the video, then read the different exercises below, then watch the video again. If you find the video helpful, please press the happy social media buttons (like) or leave a comment or question on youtube or email me directly. 

 

Here's the link: http://youtu.be/0WsfHjyacxY

 

1. Salute (dry land)

 

Stand in front of a mirror. Hold your forearm in front of you like it is in a cast with your hand over your opposite hip. 

 

Let your hand relax, and then raise your arm until you can almost salute yourself. 

 

This is pretty much how you should be moving your arm in the recovery. By swinging your elbow away from your body. 

 

Practice it with both arms. Relax your shoulder completely. Watch your shoulder: it should not rise up as you swing your arm up. 

 

Let your wrist relax. If you have any discomfort in your shoulder, adjust the angle of your upper arm at your shoulder joint.

 

This often feels strange and ridiculous to many swimmers. Swimmers who have been used to doing the chicken wing recovery for years. Take your time to discover this new movement. 

 

And very important - use a mirror or watch your arm, shoulder and elbow with your eyes - to make sure that you're not just doing what feels natural: the chicken wing. 

 

Arm in cast position 

 

Now raise your elbow, swinging it away from your body. 

 

Mid-recovery

 

 

And all the way, elbow above the shoulder, while keeping the shoulder relaxed and down.
 
Salute position

 

2. Stroke Rehearsal: Keep an Eye on Your Hands

 

Standing in front of a mirror or in waist deep water, pretend to swim. Practice the recovery movement with your body at a 75 degree angle (more or less) to the mirror and swing your elbow out and bring it forward until you can see your wrist and hand. 

 

If you now look at your arm, it should be obviously in front of your chest. 

 

Repeat on both sides, and then try a full stroke. 

 

Here are some example photos, but you'll see how this works in the video:

 

Front view of recovery

 

 

And now from the side....

 

 

Side view of recovery

And now leaning forward, you could do this in the water while standing or in a switch drill with fins on. As you can see, if looked straight ahead, I'd be able to see my hand in my peripheral vision. Try it!

 

And then rehearse each stroke happening only when you get to this position. 

 

Side view of recovery 2

 

3. The Pyramid Recovery (on a soft surface)

 

Try the following on a bed. Lie with your lead arm dangling over the edge. Make sure your body is in streamline with one hip down on the bed and the other up. Let your nose rest on the bed. 

 

Put your arm fist own next to your head so that your bent arm forms a pyramid. 

 

Then move your recovering arm back and forth to this position. 

 

See the video for a detailed description of this: http://youtu.be/0WsfHjyacxY


 

4. Push Hands with Fins

 

To gain better body awareness of your arms, elbows and hands during the recovery and to help relax the shoulder, try the Hand Push drill described at the end of the video. 

 

Kicking in streamline with fins, slowly push the back of your hand into the water up to your wrist and push it gently but firmly forward until it has moved past your shoulder.  

 

You'll know when to switch sides when the pressure on the back of your hand drops (because your hand has moved from a vertical position to an angled position).  

 

Then switch sides with a stroke smoothly but crisply.

 

Breathe on your side and then repeat. 

 

Try this on a 3-4 second count. Use your kick to provide stability and to keep you moving forward. 

 

As you grow familiar with the drill, try relaxing your shoulders and focus on swinging your elbow away from your body to initiate the recovery motion. 

 

Then when you swim, do the same thing, but with your hands just above the surface of the water during the recovery phase. 

 

Overall, to gain more awareness of your arm recovery, shoulder position, body position and tension level, slow….things….down. 

 

5. Full Stroke Focus Points

  • Relax your shoulders. Sounds simple but for most swimmers it's challenging. 
  • Keep your elbow wet. Leave your stroking arm in the water as you finish your pull. This helps remind you not to pull your elbow across your body as you prepare for the recovery.  
  • Swing wide, then high. Most of us will instinctively pull back and then try to swing the elbow up. Problem is, your shoulder is already jammed and the best you'll be able to do without hurting your shoulder is to swing far too wide on the arm recovery. 
  • Shun the Zipper. Avoid the zipper drill or anything where you trace your hand along your body during a recovery motion. Try it on dry land - you won't be able to lift your elbow very high above your shoulder while your hand is touch the side of your torso - and you shouldn't (unless you're a super-flexible Olympian or pro-triathlete who can afford shoulder surgery).

 

Final Words

 

It sounds like a lot, but it is worth it to you to spend some time exploring the sensations of your shoulder, slowing things down and trying out these exercises and drills. 

 

Do you want to swim without pain? Attention to these points will help you keep your shoulders healthy and swim faster with less effort. 


 

Next blog post:

 

Part III: How good kicking technique helps you relax your shoulders even more and...swim faster.